Ah, the sunny fresh feeling of breaking out a brand new post tag. Election 2011.
Yesterday was Budget Day. For a politics geek—like myself—this was a sort of Christmas, in the purely secular sense. Because a budget, in a minority parliament, means a chance for the opposition parties to defeat the government. On big issues like budgets, there has to be a certain level of consensus, see, and yesterday there was not. Ergo, unless last minute concessions are made, we’re headed for a election in May.
The budget itself wasn’t all that bad, actually. Driving home from work I was able to listen to most of the speech from the throne and it sounded pretty good to me. There were concessions in there for the NDP, whose support the Conservatives needed if they wanted to pass the budget, and there was nothing overly ridiculous or offense. But in the end, it wasn’t enough for Jack Layton and as he has so often done over the past four years he held the balance of power, and this time decided to drop the writ.
Weeks prior, Michael Ignatieff and his Liberals spoke out against the upcoming budget. Ignatieff highlighted some pretty serious concerns facing Stephen Harper’s Conservatives like several RCMP investigations, two historic breaches of parliamentary trust, and some pretty hefty spending on things like fighter jets. The Liberals wouldn’t support the budget of a government that, they said, the people of Canada couldn’t trust. Fair enough; as official opposition it’s their job to oppose the government when they think it’s the right thing to do. A lot of liberals (small “l”) would say that this was a long time coming, and they might be right.
So with the Liberals already lined up against the Conservatives, along with the Bloc (surprise), it was up to Mr. Layton to decide the fate of the government. Weighing the amount of concessions in the federal budget against what the New Democrats had asked for, Jack decided that the needs of middle class Canadians hadn’t been met and that he couldn’t support the budget as it stood.
It’s true that every budget is a kind of political calculation but this is certainly more true in a minority government. The Conservatives hold a balance of power, not the balance of power, and need the support of at least some other members of parliament to operate. In the past, they’ve had that support, and it’s come through making concessions especially during budget time. In the past they’ve catered to Liberal, NDP, and Bloc interests in the hopes of appeasing them and getting their budgets put through. In part, all parties worked together to make things work for Canadians. During the recession this was important. But even in the early days of Stephen Harper’s government his budgets were filled with New Democrat concessions and this was ordinary.
But this budget was different, in my opinion, this was an election budget and I have a sneaky suspicion that it was perhaps never meant to pass.
Read the rest of this article »